4 Bay Hill Road, Leonardo, NJ 07737

$999,900
Property Type: Residential Bedrooms: 3 Baths: 2 Square Footage: 2,793 Status: Closed
Current Price: $999,900 List Date: 7/24/2026 Last Modified: 9/17/2026

Overview

Description

Some homes get passed from owner to owner. This one never did. Held by the same family since day one, this spacious ranch in the Navesink section of Middletown has been cared for the way only a first and only owner cares for a home. Every system tended, every corner kept. What that leaves behind is rare: a residence that is genuinely clean and well cared for, waiting for its next family to write the chapter that renovation will bring. Spanning more than 2,700 square feet on a single level, the layout gives real room to move. Three bedrooms and two full baths anchor the home, and an additional office or flex room converts easily into a fourth bedroom for whoever needs the space.

Supplements: A paver driveway leads in past manicured landscaping, and the fully fenced backyard offers privacy that established neighborhoods like this one rarely give up. The bones are ready. A brand new roof and new Roth double-wall oil tanks mean the expensive work is already done, along with a security system and a private elevator that reaches both the g ...

Listing Details MLS# 22621887

Contract Info

Start Showing Date
2026-07-24
List Price/SqFt
349.09
Property Sub-Type
Single Family Residence
Sub-Type
Detached
New Construction
No

Location

House Number
4
Street Name
Bay Hill
Street Suffix
Road
County
Monmouth
Municipality
Middletown (MID)
Postal City
Leonardo
State
NJ
Zip Code
07737
Area/Section
Leonardo
Complex/Subdivision
None
Elementary School
Navesink Elementary
Middle School
Bayshore
High School
Middle South
Other High
Christian Bros
Directions
Take Portland Rd. to Hill Lane to Bay Hill Road

General Property Info

Full Baths
2
Total Baths
2
# Level 1 - Baths
2
Apx SqFt
2793
# Levels
Yes
Apx Year Built
1976
Garage
Yes
# Car Garage
2
HOA
No
Pool
No
Waterfront
No
Waterview
Yes

Tax and Legal

Taxes
12865
Tax Year
2025

Status Change Info

Under Contract Date
2026-07-30
Sold Date
2026-09-16

More Information

Property Features

Style: Ranch Interior: Bonus Room; Built-in Features; Elevator; First Floor Bedroom; Sliding Doors Foyer: Ceramic Tile; Double Door Entry Living Room: Floor - Wood Dining Room: Floor - Wood Kitchen: Ceramic Tile Primary Bedroom: Floor - Wood; Full Bath; Walk-in Closet Primary Bath: Ceramic Tile; Shower Stall Basement: Full; Walk-Out Access Floors: Ceramic Tile; Wood Cooling: Central Air Heating: Forced Air; Oil Above Ground Water Heater: Electric Exterior: Deck; Fence; Porch - Open; Security System Garage: Attached; Direct Access; Oversized Siding: Aluminum Siding; Brick Roof: Shingle Parking: Double Wide Drive; Driveway; Paver Block Included: Dishwasher; Dryer; Electric Cooking; Refrigerator; Stove Hood; Washer Lot Description: Fenced Area; Near Golf Course; Treed Lots; Wooded Assessment Status: Assessment - N/A Showing: Showing Time Rooms: Basement; Bathroom; Bedroom; Bonus Room; Dining Room; Family Room; Kitchen; Laundry; Living Room; Pantry; Primary Bathroom; Primary Bedroom Basement Level: Basement Bathroom Level: First Primary Bathroom Level: First Bedroom Level: First Dining Room Level: First Family Room Level: First Kitchen Level: First Laundry Level: First Living Room Level: First Primary Bedroom Level: First

Room Information

Room Name Length Level Width Dimensions
Living Room 19.00 First 20.00 19 x 20
Kitchen 12.00 First 16.00 12 x 16
Laundry 14.00 First 5.00 14 x 5
Pantry 8.00 5.00 8 x 5
Dining Room 13.00 First 16.00 13 x 16
Family Room 13.00 First 18.00 13 x 18
Family Room 13.00 First 21.00 13 x 21
Bonus Room 13.00 11.00 13 x 11
Primary Bedroom 19.00 First 13.00 19 x 13
Primary Bathroom 8.00 First 4.00 8 x 4
Bedroom 13.00 First 12.00 13 x 12
Bedroom 13.00 First 11.00 13 x 11
Bathroom 11.00 First 9.00 11 x 9
Basement 33.00 Basement 60.00 33 x 60
IDX
Listing Office: EXP Realty
Listing Agent: Geraldine Ciaccia
Source MLS Verified
Last Updated: September - 17 - 2026
The data relating to real estate on this web site comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of the MLS of the Monmouth Ocean Regional REALTORS®, and site contains live data. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.